“The Top New York Rangers Fan Favorites Of All Time”: Looking At Every Beloved Blueshirt Through Each Era, A Complete & Detailed Rangers’ Alumni Game Report; Lundqvist Gets The Loudest Reaction – Then Scores an Empty Net Goal Too! “The 2026-27 New York Rangers Progress Report” At The Quarter-Pole of the Season; Grades & Reviews of Each Player, Dingorfeyev Dinged Up Ahead of Montreal Milestone Game, Latest NYR News (We Have a Trade!) & More

We have a non GAME REVIEW blog tonight, with plenty of topics to discuss, including my promised-and-belated “Top New York Rangers Fan Favorites of All Time,” “The 2026-27 New York Rangers Progress Report,” and a recap of Sunday’s Blueshirts’ alumni game. We also have some news and a trade to discuss too!

Greetings and salutations everyone and welcome to another blog here on BlueCollarBlueShirts.com. If you can believe it, then the Rangers have already completed 25% of their 2026-27 regular season schedule.

Where does the time go?

Heck, I also asked that question to myself about one hundred times over when watching Sunday’s matinee Rangers v. Blueshirts alumni game – as no joke – and I am now older than half of these retirees!

As noted up top, then there is a lot to get into, and where yes, I know that I could’ve broken up this blog into 6778678798696798 different articles – but you know how I roll – one big-ass blog in my dedicated/allotted writing time and that’s that!

I also know that I could’ve saved some of this for the upcoming mini-break, as after Monday night against Montreal and the Rangers will have five days off; but there is also that little video game coming out this week too, and you may have heard about it as well – “Grand Theft Auto VI.”

(Yes, I’m 44-years-old and still play video games – and where only the Rockstar releases are the non-sports games that I play around with.)

Combine my busy work schedule with everything else, then I thought I’d give you everything here – and then you can decide how much of this you want to read at once!

Let’s roll, but of course for those of you who may have missed it, then here is where I last left off – the Rangers’ pummel job of the Vancouver Canucks:

NYR/VAN 11/13 Review: “GAWD DANG!” Rangers Terrorize and Horrify Crappy Canucks On Friday The 13th; Newest Blueshirt Turns Vancouver Into “Madison Square GAWDIN!” Successful Homecomings Galore; Garand Theft Auto Does It Again, “The Concussed Czech” Returns; Chytil Looks As Weak As Ever, Blueshirts Enjoy a Fantastic Road-Trip; Miller Gets Last Laugh In A Laughter Of A Game, Sully Sons Rempe, Padding The Box Score, Richter v. Lundqvist, M$GN, Kreider (Maybe) Next & More


I thought Sunday’s alumni game was a raving success – while also doubling-up as an entertaining way to spend two hours. Photo Credit: NYR

As noted in my Rangers/Canucks GAME REVIEW, then I wasn’t going to be able to attend Sunday’s Blueshirts’ alumni game, and mainly due to the noon puck drop.

After all, then the huge UFC card, which was also held at M$G (on Saturday night) didn’t end until 1AM!

And once again – kudos to the M$G events staff – because they flipped the building from a UFC octagon spectacular to a hockey arena during the wee hours of the morning.


The players and two teams that we saw on Sunday afternoon. Of note: Team Centennial wore last year’s powder blue third jerseys while Team Classic wore last season’s Winter Classic jersey. What a way to boost merchandise sales! Photo Credit: NYR

If you browse the list of names above, then if you’re like me, then you must also think that we had a pretty good representation from the many generations/eras of Rangers’ hockey.

There are few roster – and non-roster too – thoughts from this game that I had:

One, where was Brian Leetch?

After all, then the other members of the Core Four of 1994, Mark Messier, Adam Graves and Mike Richter, were all there – and where in addition – it was actually Saint Adam, #9, that set up this entire event.

How Graves doesn’t have a statue in front of M$G yet is beyond me.

When it comes to the greatest defenseman in franchise history, then I’ve been told by some who would know that Leetch has had a falling out with the Team President, Chris Drury.

That said, then this rumor is 100% unconfirmed – and that’s all it is – a rumor (with a tad of speculation too).

Furthermore, then it was Leetch’s buddy, Graves, that set up this event, so I can’t see Leetch rebuffing him over some sort of speculated spat with Drury.

After all, then it was Drury himself who stabbed his former boss in the back, John Davidson – and as the Pizza Man Team President/General Manager did some five years ago.

I bring this up because JD has been back at M$G multiple times over since his unceremonious exit, and mainly in support of one of his best friends, Sam Rosen.

Perhaps the most likely reason for this most notable omission?

Leetch was impacted by Friday’s flight shutdown.

And for all we know, then maybe he had some other thing to do on Sunday afternoon.


Two, Gilles Villemure, who beat brain cancer, was in-attendance – but he was never brought up during the M$GN broadcast.

I don’t know or not if Villemure is the oldest Ranger still alive today, but at 86-years-old, then he obviously wasn’t going to play in this game.

And maybe he was honored in front of the live audience – but again – nothing from the TV side of things.

(I’ll say it later below – but just to say it now – and thank the hockey gods that M$GN decided to share this event with us.)


Three, I don’t know who was supposed to play in net for Team White (Classic), but Mike Richter, now at sixty-years-old, was never going to return to the pipes.

In regards to Richter, then he adopted a position from hockey’s yesteryear – the rover position (hybrid defenseman/forward).

This was a position that Art Ross once made famous.

While Henrik Lundqvist, who has become a fixture at these alumni events ever since his retirement, did play (and much more on him below); then it was the Hartford Wolf Pack goalie coach, Brendan Burke, that played opposite of THE KING OF COMMENTARY.

I only bring this up because it was telling that the worst goalie in franchise history, and a current-and-lousy M$GN employee today, Sieve Vagistat, wasn’t there.

After all, then Vagistat is local (he lives in Connecticut).

That said, and to be fair, then maybe he had something to do, because for as much as I can’t stand his work on M$GN, then, and by all accounts, and he’s one hell of a family man.

He’s also an avid skier, so he could’ve been on the slopes for all that I know too.


Four, I can’t believe how young some of these guys are.

Hell, Boo Nieves, who has been retired for years and always an active participant at all of these alumni events, is only 32-years-old.

He also retired at 26-years-old, while only logging 76 games for the Rangers during the last rebuilding period, due to concussions.

More power to him for prioritizing his health – as that’s more than I can say about Filip Chytil these days.

And not to knock Nieves, but if he’s an honored member of the alumni, then who is next, Emerson FN Etem?

(I only bring up Etem because whenever I see Carl Hagelin, then my Blueshirts’ blood still continues to boil over that trade – and save me the salary cap talk too – as I wanted Senile Glen Sather to pay Hags at the time.)


While he may have given up five goals in his team’s 8-5 victory, then without question, Lundqvist came off as the biggest star while also providing a memory that no one will forget anytime soon. I fully expect never-ending replays of his empty net goal on M$GN broadcasts in the days, months and years to come!

There’s no point in recapping every play from an alumni/charity game, as after all, this was all about having fun and raising money for the franchise’s/James Dolan’s Garden of Dreams charity.

If there is anything that I want to stress here, then it is that this game was extremely entertaining.

I had a blast watching it – and after it – I was kicking myself for not sacrificing sleep in order to attend it.

And aside from a few jersey retirement ceremonies during the past twenty-years, then I can’t remember so much Ranger star power and fan-favorites all under the same roof at once.

This type of event also made me wonder if some sort of convention, featuring all of these fan-favorites, would be profitable. (Hotels and flights would be a big factor.)


I usually don’t care about Ranger gear, as the only thing that I care about are wins, but I must admit – then Lundqvist’s pads were slick and keen. Photo Credit: NYR

I was wondering about two things heading into the game.

One, would Derek Stepan yell at Lundqvist again if #30 got crotchety in net again, and if so, then would Lundqvist have him traded to the other team?!?!?

Joke aside, then my other thought, one from the land of seriousness, was would the team say anything about Ron Duguay.

Fortunately, then Doogie was honored:

Ron Duguay’s #10 jersey not only hung in the locker room, but behind both benches too. M$GN also reran the tribute video they made when he passed away. Photo Credit: NYR

I thought it was classy that the Rangers, and despite ignoring him and his pleas for help when he was alive, paid tribute to Duguay at the game.

I guess it’s better late than never – but I also know how much the Rangers’ refusal to talk to him when he needed it the most just absolutely demoralized him.

It also still irks me that there are no #10 decals on the helmets and/or Doogie patches on the jerseys.

At the very least, and with Duguay’s family still requesting financial assistance in order to cover past medical bills and the upcoming celebration of life ceremony (according to Duguay’s daughter Shay, then he has been cremated), and the Blueshirts could’ve sold some sort of item, and whether it be a decal, patch or something else – and then take the proceeds and donate it to his family.

And yep – it still bothers me how the Rangers just flat-out dismissed him when he was alive – and as he made public during the final months/years of his life.

That’s also why I thought it was callous, cruel and ignorant when John Giannone, during an intermission break, said that Duguay would have loved to been at this event.

Giannone never mentioned how Duguay regularly shared on social media how his requests to play in these types of games were ignored and/or turned down during his final years.

But I’ll end it here – as I don’t want to dampen what was really a positive event.

I also won’t bring up for the 78678678967986789679867986986th time how this event would’ve been a perfect time to hang banners for the true Ranger legends that deserve them – Frank Boucher, the Cook brothers, Lester Patrick, Ron Greschner, Emile Francis, Ching Johnson and Bryan Hextall either.

Sometimes, it’s tough being a fan of this franchise – but again – I don’t want to let this negativity mar what otherwise was a perfect afternoon at M$G.


The Rangers raised nearly $300,000 for needy kids on Sunday. Photo Credit: NYR

After an Oprah Winfrey doppleganger sang an amazing rendition of the National Anthem, then I had three thoughts when I first saw the players take the ice.

One, I still miss Carl Hagelin, who today, is a scout (European) for the Minnesota Wild.

Two, then Derek Stepan, who also works with the Wild, will one day be behind an NHL bench.

Three, then it was fun to see Marc Staal and Dan Girardi back together, and where hopefully one day – Ryan McDonagh will be right there with them.


Like everyone else on those 2013-14 and 2014-15 Rangers, and it pains me that none of these two teams couldn’t cross the finish line. And oh – don’t get me started on the dump Anton Stralman/sign Dan Boyle fiasco again either! It was also no surprise that Stralman played on Sunday, while Boyle was nowhere to be found! Photo Credit: NYR

Lundqvist made a few saves to open the game, and where immediately – the familiar-and-friendly “HEN-RIK” chants returned to M$G.

While it is easier to cheer for a goalie after a save when opposed to cheering for a skater in-game, and while there is also a recency/younger generation bias too, but Lundqvist easily received the loudest cheers all-game.

This kind of surprised me and only because Mark Messier was there too.

But had Messier, who turns 66-years-old in two months, had scored?

Then maybe we would have heard such thunderous and deserved ovations.

After Girardi (M$GN did many player interviews in-game) told us that he has a six-foot sixteen-year-old playing in the OHL, then another Rangers’ defenseman, the recently retired Brendan Smith, scored the game’s first goal against Lundqvist.

Lundqvist looked pissed afterwards – and this was pretty funny (Dave Maloney, who called the game along with Sam Rosen, also brought this up).

Another one of Lundqvist’s former teammates, Derick “BIG GAME BRASS” Brassard, put Team Classic up 2-0 just a minute or so later.

(It was also great to see Brassard back – and where like many of you – and I have fond memories of that era – and even if we didn’t see the ultimate goal get accomplished.)

Following the Brassard goal, then I saw Colin Stephenson, of Newsday, report on the on-going Rangers’ practice at their training facility in Tarrytown.

With no Knicks game to be had at M$G after this alumni game (the basketball team was in Toronto), then I thought an opportunity was lost – as the Rangers, following this alum match, could have allowed fans to stay and then watch the team of today practice.

While other teams in the league allow fans to watch practices; then it’s very rare when the Rangers do the same.

After the lovable Rosen said something like “Derick Brassard, pardon me Joe, Derek Dorsett, pardon me, I mean you Dave,” then Messier, now a senior citizen, had something like a 3:00 shift.

Wow.

Following that line, and M$G pumped-in Maloney and Rosen’s commentary into the building for a brief time, and just only so the fans in-attendance could hear from two other members of the alum (yes, I consider Rosen as “Rangers’ Alum” – and where I think he also deserves a banner in the rafters of M$G too).

Boo Nieves scored his first of three hat trick goals for Team Centennial in order to bring the game to 2-1.

However, and in some Swedish-on-Swedish violence – and Hagelin beat his friend Lundqvist in order to return Team Classic’s two-goal lead.

This game, contested under two twenty-five-minute halves (and a running clock too), went to intermission with this 3-1 score.


My favorite Rangers’ alumni game memory is when they did the Christopher Reeve charity game. In a staged & entertaining fight (I think 2000), WWE’s Chris Jericho “fought” his father, a member of one of the best third lines in franchise history, Ted Irvine. I just wish I still had my two disposable camera’s (remember those?) worth of pictures from that day! Photo Credit: Chris Jericho

To open the second half, then we were relayed this “BREAKING NEWS”:

As Graves would say after the game, then Mark Messier doesn’t do these events often, and in turn, he wanted to allow every member of the alumni to play with one of the greatest players to ever do it. Photo Credit: M$GN

Jasper Fast, another recent retiree, brought Team Centennial back within one with his 3-2 goal.

But just like the last time Team Classic decreased the lead, and there was Team Centennial to return their lead to two goals – as porn star Lisa Ann’s favorite player, Michael Del Zotto, brought the score to 4-2.

Following the goal and Giannone interviewed Captain Cally at the bench. I thought Giannone missed a chance here – as the broadcaster should’ve asked the former #24 about the current #24 of today, Tye Kartye – as both #24’s play a similar style of game.

If you recall, then Dorsett, forced to retire over crippling back injuries and medical conditions, just fired a rocket of a shot when scoring Team Centennial’s 4-3 goal.

Nieves then scored his second of three when tying the score at four-all.

The tie was short-lived, as Aaron Varos gave Team Centennial their first lead of the game with his 5-4 goal – and while you never have much defense at any of these charity games – but it was noticeable here that everyone abandoned such an idea!

Another tie was soon again quickly erased, as Hagelin scored his second against Lundqvist when upping the score at five goals a side.

This would also be the last goal for Team Classic.

“The Ironman,” Dan Girardi, scored the eventual game-winning goal when giving Team Centennial a 6-5 lead.

Nieves then scored his hat trick goal, his third, to put the team ahead 7-5.

And with the Team Classic net empty?

Then a highlight you’ll see on M$GN broadcasts for some time to come:


8-5, and 8-5 your final too, following the first empty net goal of Henrik Lundqvist’s career – and even if it took a charity game for such an event to transpire!


Lundqvist, in his post-game interview with Giannone, joked about being lousy in net after surrendering five goals (he even then tried to be serious and blame his rust & gear – a true athlete to the end!), but he was more than ecstatic with his ENG – and where to say it – then this wasn’t any sort of prearranged event either. Photo Credit: M$GN

To conclude this recap (and probably the longest report of this event that you’ll find too), then this was a fun way to spend two hours.

And kudos to M$GN, and at the risk of hurting live ticket sales, for airing it.

After all, then as we all know – and the Rangers usually keep everyone in the dark – and whether it be exhibition/preseason games, Chris Drury ZOOM ZOOM calls, practices, you name it, you know it.

Instead of past practices and the Rangers illuminated everyone on Sunday.

And they raised a lot of bucks for a great cause too.

Win-win.


The recent passing of Ron Duguay sparked this idea and finally, I’m now giving you something here!

To go hand-in-hand with the alumni game, a contest that featured a bevy and a bundle of Blueshirts’ favorites, then I thought this was the perfect opportunity to present to you the following:

“The Top Fifteen New York Ranger Favorites of All Time.”


Two former captains, Messier & Cally, most certainly made the final cut. Photo Credit: NYR

Just a few thoughts before getting into what obviously can be a debated listing.

This idea, expanded to a higher number, could be a good (coffee table) book idea.

However, then I feel like I’ve pretty much covered all of these players in my past books – and if you don’t know about my previous works of art – then check out the PLUGS segment below.

(After all, then my first book covers everyone below – but not in any type of order. And since I’ve already written about these players in long-form, then I’m just giving you a few sentences on each player for this list.)

As usual with any sort of list of this nature, then there is a generational bias.

I tried to keep mine out of it.

I just say this to say that someone may favor Eddie Giacomin over Henrik Lundqvist (and vice-versa) – and for the obvious reason – you are always loyal to the player that you personally grew up.

After all, then that’s why nostalgia always sells and works – and just like this alumni game did from Sunday too.

While I really had no scientific formula when cutting down – and then presenting only fifteen players afterwards – but I did consider crowd cheers, jersey sales, league-wide popularity and other factors when giving you this list.

I say this because such factors give players of the modern era an edge – as you really didn’t have these things during bygone eras.

Heck, you barely had women in the crowd until guys like Rod Gilbert and Ron Duguay came around.

And there was no fan wearing a Frank Boucher jersey in the 1920s, nor was anyone following what Bill Cook was doing on a daily basis either – and as opposed to today – where you can follow any player, from any of the league’s 32-team days, everyday.

Do I even have to say it?

Then for those who don’t know – and the Rangers weren’t even on television, much less any sort of streaming service, during their first forty-years either!

I also limited this list to only the Rangers’ alumni and NHL retirees – and where one day – then I could see the likes of Adam Fox, CZAR IGOR, Chris Kreider and even Mika Zibanejad (I told you – I took my own biases out of the equation) leap-frogging some of these names.

Furthermore, then once retired, and for sure, and players like Mats Zuccarello and Artemi Panarin, both ironically in Los Angeles today, would receive consideration.

And really, I’m only doing this to spotlight players who deserve praise.

This is all meant to be fun – and this isn’t some end-all, be-all, definitive list.

With that said, let’s get into it – but because I want to showcase/name-drop as many players as possible, then the following names were considered, but didn’t make the final cut:

Sean Avery, Jeff Beukeboom (my personal favorite), Bill Cook, John Davidson, Tie Domi, Brandon Dubinsky, Jan Erixon, Phil Esposito (some loved him, some hated him because of his Boston tenure-  and later on – his “Trader Phil” days), Anders Hedberg, Marian Gaborik, Wayne Gretzky (and you can argue that he belongs anyway despite his short tenure), Dan Girardi, Vic Hadfield, Jaromir Jagr, Ching Johnson, Pierre Larouche, Edgar Laprade, Don Maloney, Stephane Matteau, Don Murdoch, Mark Pavelich, Ulf Nilsson, Brad Park, James Patrick, Dean Prentice, Don “Bones” Raleigh, Chuck Rayner, Marty St. Louis, Pete Stemkowski, Walt Tkaczuk, John Vanbiesbrouck and Steve Vickers.

And of course, there were also many short-term names, and players from generations ago, not listed here, that were further considered.


It’s always been my opinion that Mike Richter was the greatest Rangers’ goalie of all-time – but it’s also my belief that Henrik Lundqvist was more popular. And really, shouldn’t that be the case when you consider the rosters these two goalies had? (Richter had more star power – and played with two of the greatest Rangers in franchise history. The same can’t be said about Lundqvist.) Photo Credit: Steiner Sports

15. Nick Fotiu: The Staten Island born Fotiu will always be remembered for his tough play, willingness to fight and for throwing souvenir pucks to the blue seats. The two-stint Ranger still remains as an ambassador for the franchise today.


14. Gump Worsley: The goalie played behind some of the worst teams in franchise history, but The Gumper always gave them a chance. Between besmirching the idea of wearing a mask (he was a tough guy), regularly recording 40+ saves per game, his daily bouts with head coach Phil Watson and all of his quotable quotes – and Worsley would’ve been a social media sensation had such a thing been around in his day.


13. Ryan Callahan: One of the first and most prominent members of the alumni to go south to Tampa during the mid-2010s. Captain Cally will always be remembered as the leader of “The Black & Blueshirts,” a team that focused on blocking shots under head coach John Tortorella like no other. There aren’t many former captains of this club that embodied the role like he did.


12. Frank Boucher: Yeah, you may accuse me of a personal bias here, but someone from his era had to be represented here. That said, and he made hockey popular in New York when the sport was still in its infancy in The Big Apple. He scored every game-winning goal in the 1928 Stanley Cup Final and spent thirty-years with the Rangers too. While not as controversial/adversarial as Worlsey was (Boucher did win three Cups here after all!); but Boucher was also a reporter’s dream, as he always had a good quote, and perhaps a beer too, at the ready.


11. Harry Howell: Howell, a defenseman, and who was also the youngest team captain in franchise history until Dave Maloney came around (both men were 22-years-old, Maloney beat Howell by a few days), played from 1952-1969 in New York. To this day, and his 1,160 regular season career games played still holds up as a franchise record. A former Norris Trophy winner, and his #3 remains in the rafters of M$G. As a long-time pillar, then he was arguably the most popular Ranger of two different eras.


Perhaps Duguay deserves to be ranked higher than #10, but I couldn’t resist.

10. Ron Duguay: I think Dave Maloney described Duguay’s impact the best – and as he did on Sunday during the alumni game: “Duguay took over from Rod Gilbert – and then went to heights that nobody could have ever imagined.” While there were a few female fans during the days of both Gilbert and Giacomin; but it was Duguay that brought in the opposite sex to the Garden during his heyday.

For more on Duguay, then check out: https://bluecollarblueshirts.com/102226/


9. Andy Bathgate: Like Doogie, and I admit it – I went with Bathgate’s number, #9, when listing him here. When Bathgate left New York for Toronto in 1963 (and where once traded to Leaf Land – then he finally won the Stanley Cup that had long eluded him throughout his entire 10-year career), then he held every Rangers’ scoring record imaginable. Granted, he played in longer seasons than his predecessors (and where the players who succeeded Bathgate then played in longer seasons than him too); but for many fans, then it was #9 who was the greatest Ranger of all-time – and even if he didn’t have the hardware to show for it.


8. Brian Leetch: I had a tough time when trying to decide where to place the greatest Rangers’ defenseman of all-time – as this is a popularity list and not a best-of-the-best list. When it comes to these final eight, an ELITE EIGHT, if you will, then I just think Leetch wasn’t as popular as the others you’ll see below. I don’t know how best to describe it, but I don’t think Leetch ever cherished the aura and delight that he often brought to the fans.


7. Mike Richter: While he’s the greatest goalie in Rangers’ history in my eyes; then I’m not so sure if he’s even the most popular, much less second-most popular either. As noted above, he played on some stacked teams during his prime years, and like Leetch, then the love during his days in Rangerstown, USA was spread around pretty equally. Other players on this list, both before and after him, didn’t have that same luxury. But make no bones about it – and #35 was always beloved by the Garden Faithful.


6. Jean Ratelle: To this day, even now 51-years after it happened, and some fans will declare that the Ratelle/Park/Zanussi for Esposito/Vadnais trade to Boston was the absolute worst in franchise history. (I’m not one of these people – and you can read my “Tricks of the Trade” book for more about this deal – and what I think what was the worst trade too.) However you may feel about the deal, then this much is true: This five-player swap remains the biggest trade in NHL history – and that even includes when Gretzky left Edmonton for L.A. too. Gentleman Jean will always hold a special place for fans who once saw the GAG Line shine on Broadway.


If you consider Graves post-retirement work with the Rangers, then you could make a case that he should be ranked first-overall on this list.

5. Adam Graves: I’ve referred to Graves as a “saint” many times over – and for my most detailed recap of one of the greatest Rangers, then I refer you to this link: https://bluecollarblueshirts.com/7622/. Simply put, and there’s nothing new that I can add that I haven’t said before – including how he’s now even putting together alumni games.


Three eras of Rangers’ goaltending together. Photo Credit: NYR

4. Eddie Giacomin: Similar to Graves, then I refer you to something that I previously wrote, where this time, it was Giacomin’s obituary: https://bluecollarblueshirts.com/91725/. Without getting repetitive, then EDDIE, EDDIE, EDDIE! to some, is the most popular Ranger of all-time. There will also never be a game that proved as such – and as was the case back on 11/2/1975.


3. Rod Gilbert: This entry doesn’t need to be explained either, and for more on the man known as “Mr. Ranger,” then check out: https://bluecollarblueshirts.com/gilbertrip/.


In my eyes, then no two men were more popular in New York than Mark Messier and Henrik Lundqvist. That’s why it’s a treat to see that they have close relationship – and where it’s also unfortunate that M$GN hasn’t reunited them yet – as both work the league’s national broadcasts to this very day (Messier ESPN, Lundqvist TNT). Photo Credit: NYR

2. Henrik Lundqvist: The crowd was never louder at M$G than it was in 1994, but even with the “EDDIE!” chants considered – and I don’t think that I’ve ever heard a player regularly receive louder ovations than Lundqvist did with the “HEN-RIK” chants. As noted earlier, and those chants will never die – and where no one received more chants (and loud ones at that) than Lundqvist did at the recent alumni game.


1. Mark Messier: Winning will make you popular which is why Messier, despite being known more as an Oiler than as a Ranger in some circles, takes the top spot. Lundqvist didn’t have as much talent around him as “The Messiah” did during his first run in The Big Apple, but Messier was not only more successful than his fellow Hall of Fame peer – but he was also the reason why so many top names raced to New York too. No disrespect to Bill Cook, as the times and parameters couldn’t be any more different – but Messier will always be remembered as the greatest captain in franchise history – and as the man who broke the 54-year curse.


I’ve been using this simple and basic graphic since 2013! Over a dozen years and still runnin’ strong! Photo Credit: Public Domain

I know that I’m approaching another ungodly word-count right now, so since this is only a progress report card at the quarter-pole of the season, then, and unlike past years, I’ll keep it short.

(Or at least short for me!)

But don’t fret yet – as I will give you another one of my monstrosities some 21 games from now – which is when it will be time to do the Mid-Season Report Card.

Before getting into everything, then just a few general statements about the team at the 25% mark of the season:

As noted all-summer then into this campaign – and I never thought the Rangers had a shot at making the playoffs.

Today?

Then I’m losing my pre-season bet to Stan Fischler!

Presently, and with 21 games played out of the 84 that are scheduled, the Rangers have a winning record of 12-8-1.

Their 25-points in the standings ranks them third-best in the Metro, behind Carolina (34) and New Jersey (30).

While they do have more games played than two teams behind them, the Islanders (22-points in 19 games played) and Washington (20 points in 18 games played); then since the Rangers have to play the Islanders and Capitals several more times this season, then the Blueshirts still control their own fate.

For the Rangers, and as noted last week in this space, then it’s my belief that if they have any plans of becoming playoff bound, then it needs to be because they finished top-three in their division.

Currently, and the Atlantic Division is stacked – as you already have five teams that have 27-points – and where you have to think that the sixth-best team in the division, the Sabres (20 points in 20 games played), will eventually get hot too.

To restate this, then even prior to the CZAR IGOR injury – and I didn’t envision the Rangers reaching the postseason, as it’s my belief that we’re currently enduring the third Dark Age in franchise history.

If they do miss the playoffs, then that makes it three-years straight.

However, the Rangers, and I don’t think anyone can argue otherwise, are exceeding all expectations – and especially when you factor the CZAR IGOR injury into the equation.

That said, and it’s not like the FAT CAT forwards are necessarily lifting them – as instead – and it’s role, back-up and bottom-six players, such as Tye Kartye, Dylan Garand, Oliver Bjorkstrand and others, that are carrying the team on most nights.

For the Rangers to end their playoff schneid, then you simply will need to get more out of the likes of Mika Zibanejad, J.T. Miller and Pavel Dorofeyev – as it’s this trio that eats up the most money from the forward group.

And they’ll need their goaltenders to remain valiant too.


I don’t think the Rangers can expect Glenn Gawdin to carry them every game! Photo Credit: NYR

Before doling out the grades, let me give you the usual criteria that I use whenever I do these report cards:

— Grades are given out based on production, playing to their role on the team and to the contract of a player.

For example, I expect less from a fourth line and six-figure salaried player, such as a Noah Laba or an Eeli Tolvanen.

On the other hand, I expect a lot out of a first line player and/or a high-priced player like a Pavel Dorofeyev or Mika Zibanejad.

After all, we are playing in a salary-cap world, where teams are constantly giving up quality players, even players they drafted, in order to compete.

— To ignore the salary-cap hit of a player would be foolish, which is why they are considered and factored into these grades.

Keep in mind, to me, a player’s salary-cap hit is a stat that belongs on the back of a hockey card.

When it comes to building NHL rosters, general managers look at cap hits first. They aren’t worried about Corsi’s or whatever other nerd stat that Sieve Vagistat has pulled out of his five-hole this week.

In addition, and more times than not during this present era, then you don’t see as many pure “hockey trades” when compared to bygone eras. Instead, you see more “salary-cap dump trades” than anything else. (To paraphrase Larry Brooks, then “I. Miss. Chris.”)

Lastly, and perhaps most importantly above all else – these grades are just my opinions only.

In other words – don’t get bent out of shape over them!

This is just my way of assessing the current roster at this moment in the season.

And if any grade is truly egregious, then I’m sure that you will let me know!

(As a reminder, then since we’re already into overtime, then just a grade and a quick assessment, and we’ll save the lengthy analysis for the Mid-Season Report Card. I will list/grade every player below by position.)


As is usually the case, then Adam Fox remains as the best Rangers’ skater in my eyes.

FORWARDS

COLE BEAUDOIN

Grade: Incomplete

Following the Joe Veleno injury, the rookie got four games this season, didn’t score a point in any of them and was a Rangers’ fourth line center du jour – then only to get punted back to Hartford after the failed call-up. He’s young – so he has plenty of time – but he also didn’t wow anyone during his pro try-out either.


OLIVER BJORKSTAND

Grade: B+

The Dane, on a one-year deal that pays him $4.5M, has been a pleasant surprise. His seven goals has him in a three-way tie (Gabe Perreault and Tye Kartye) for second-best on the team. He’s making the most during a contract year.


JAROSLAV CHMELAR

Grade: B-

The Czech is still on a rookie contract but his two goals as a fourth-liner work for me, hence a decent grade.

After being demoted, Chmelar, upon his return, seems to have more of an edge. Let’s hope this stays this way for him as the season moseys along.


WILL CUYLLE

Grade: A-

On a lot of nights and it’s #50 who seems like he’s doing it all. He presently has nine points, but he also leads the team, and by far, with 82 hits – which is also good for ninth-best in all of the NHL today. He’s also been willing to do anything, hence Mike Sullivan’s recent experiment of making him a third line center.


PAVEL DOROFEYEV

Grade: F+

“Dingorfeyev” may have six goals this season – but only one of them was meaningful – as the other five took place during blowouts/garbage time.

His minus-18 plus/minus rating is also DEAD-LAST in the league among the 769 players who have skated in the NHL this year.

With the money he’s paid and the Russian is trending a lot like other big named free agents in franchise history – BUST.

Let’s see him improve – and I don’t want to hear about a transition period either – as it’s not like Kartye, Garand, Bjorkstrand, Durzi, Pettersson or others needed such a thing.


JUSTIN DOWLING

Grade: Incomplete

Another fourth-line center du jour that didn’t earn a job after four games played.


GLENN GAWDIN

Grade: Incomplete

He’s played in two games thus far as the current fourth line center du jour and made the most of it against the worst team in the league (two goals v. Vancouver).


LUKE GLENDENING

Grade: Incomplete

Stop me if you heard me say this yet:

Another fourth line center du jour who played in four games. Why the Rangers even signed this fossil is beyond me – but that’s a Drury playing around with other people’s money problem and not a player problem.

What, is Glendening supposed to say no to an opportunity?


TYE KARTYE

Grade: A+

For $1.25M, and the player that anyone in the league could’ve had prior to last year’s trade deadline has become the team’s most consistent forward.

He’s top-five in every scoring category, and his 57 hits rank him second-best to only Cuylle.

Going into this season and I projected him as the 2027 Steven McDonald winner.

He may win Team MVP too.


NOAH LABA

Grade: C-

His rookie contract is the only reason why this grade isn’t lower.

While usually solid defensively – and a team player too; but through 21 games played – and he’s still seeking his first NHL goal.

Heck, CZAR IGOR, lost in the second week of the season, has more goals.


ALEXIS LAFRENIERE

Grade: B

It feels like Lafreniere has been here for a decade (he’s now in his seventh season) – and even so – and we still don’t know who he is.

He has the most goals on the team (10), but where he’s scored those goals in bunches, including two empty-netters against the Islanders.

He remains inconsistent, as you never know what version of him will show up – but he is tracking to have his best season yet.

That should be the case, as after all, and it’s only been seven years!


J.T. MILLER

Grade: B-

This grade would have been lower if the recent four-game road-trip didn’t happen.

Accepting a role on PP2, and the captain’s new man-up unit has actually had more success than the top quintet.

His 12 assists rank him third-overall on the team, while his 16-points rank him fourth-best

I’ve said so much about him in the past, and how Drury traded for him two-years too late as well – but for a guy that hoped to be a 100-point scorer in New York – and he’s nowhere close to that.


GABE PERREAULT

Grade: B+

Unlike other busts, players that never lived up to expectations, and/or prospects that didn’t come out of the gate hot, guys like Lias Andersson, Filip Chytil, Vitali Kravtsov, Kaapo Kakko, Alexis Lafreniere and Brennan Othmann – and Perreault, drafted much later than these fellow recent first-round picks, actually looks like an NHLer.

The Rangers need a homegrown forward for the future and Perreault is projecting to be that guy.

And like Kartye, it may be time to start talking extension before the price gets too high.


TAYLOR RADDYSH

GRADE: D

Why Raddysh is even here, and why did he get six games (he didn’t score a goal in any of them), remains beyond me.


MATT REMPE

Grade: Incomplete

Sullivan doesn’t like him and even when Rempe is part of a line-up that has won consecutive games, including a winning streak of three – and the head coach still staples the big man to the bench.

I don’t get it.

And when Sully is benching #73 in his hometown – then it’s time to part ways.

Let’s just hope that when that day happens – then Rempe doesn’t take over the league – and as his former fellow partner, Adam Edstrom, is now doing in Nashville.


EELI TOLVANEN

Grade: B+

A last-second free agent signing and Tolvanen (four goals) is making the most of it. Presently on a one-year deal that annually pays him $1.5M and the Swede has been extremely reliable. His plus/minus rating of +6 is the best of any Blueshirt forward today.


JOE VELENO

Grade: Incomplete

Who knows what Veleno would have done had he not been injured in the team’s fourth game this season. What I do know, is that ever since that injury – and the team is still looking for someone to take a hold of the fourth line center position.


MIKA ZIBANEJAD

Grade: C-

Obviously, Mika’s disgusting contract and the fact that he only has two even strength goals in 21 games played (and where he scored 40% of his five goals against one of the worst teams in the league) negatively impacts his grade.

He’s paid as a top superstar and plays on the team’s first line.

However, and despite being third-best on the team in points (19 – and a lot of secondary assists in there too) – he’s not scoring goals.

It’s another slow start for a player that has a history of them.

It’s just a shame the Rangers can’t pay him accordingly.


After summer rumors surrounded Gavrikov about a possible trade to a contender, and #44, now in Year 2 with the Rangers, remains as consistent as ever. Photo Credit: NYR

DEFENSEMEN

SEAN DURZI

Grade: B+

The biggest part of the Vincent Trocheck off-season trade has been a valuable asset – that is – when healthy.

The former Mormon from Utah has missed one-third of the season thus far due to injury.

We have seen what he can do – and he should be back soon enough – so let’s hope he continues to contribute once returned to the team’s second pair.


ADAM FOX

Grade: A+

The former Norris Trophy winner is playing like one this year – and finally – during a season where he’s been injury-free after missing huge chunks of time during the past two-years.

Not only does he play in all three zones, and not only is he the power-play quarterback and leader of the penalty kill too – but #23 also leads the team in assists (21), points (23), and TOI (22:56).

He’s paid to be one of the team’s best players – and he’s living up to – if not exceeding – such expectations.


VLADISLAV GAVRIKOV

Grade: A

The Russian has the best plus/minus rating on the team (+7) which is pretty amazing when you consider that only Fox plays more than him (21:30).

While not going nuts in the box score like he did last year, but again – he was never paid to do what Fox does either.

As a defensive defenseman, and as his plus/minus rating (it should be a +8 – but that Connor McDavid guy…) would suggest – and he’s been excellent in his own end.


SCOTT MORROW

Grade: B

After being made a healthy scratch for the team’s first fourteen games and Morrow has something to prove – and he’s proving it.

While he’s still seeking his first goal; but as a d-man, and he’s doing his job.

He has a +3 rating and there hasn’t been one instance where he looks out of place after spending the first six-weeks of the season on the bench.


MARCUS PETTERSSON

Grade: B+

Pettersson, along with his partner Durzi (when healthy), is a huge reason why I don’t buy the “transition period” excuse when it comes to Dorofeyev.

Both Pettersson and Durzi, and despite having never played together before, are already a well-oiled machine as the team’s second pair.


MATTHEW ROBERTSON

Grade: Incomplete

Robertson wouldn’t be here right now if it weren’t for injuries – which is a shame – as he showed promise last season.

He’s only played in four games – but at least he played in front of his hometown team (Edmonton) – which is something that Rempe can’t say.


BRADEN SCHNEIDER

Grade: C+

The new whipping boy in town – as no fan base goes after third-pair d-men like stat-geek/analytical loser Ranger fans do.

While Schneider has never lived up to his expectations following his 2021-22 rookie season – but I also don’t think he’s a horror show as many make him out to be either.

He’s been fine enough in the role that he has, but to expect him to ever live up to the “BABY TROUBA” nickname, one first coined by the former captain himself, is just unrealistic.

If I don’t dislike him as much as the majority do, then why the low grade?

Easy – he’s making $5.5M on a prove me contract – and all he’s proved is the status quo.


ALBERTS SMITS

Grade: C+

Smits is on a rookie deal and is only eighteen-years-old.

Presently out with injury and the fresh-faced kid has missed the past four games.

Smits is still searching for his first NHL point.

He hasn’t been really that bad defensively.

While he’s made a few mistakes – but what teenage rookie doesn’t?

That said, then I still would’ve approached him in the same way that I said following the Rangers’ selection of him:

Send him to Hartford.


We’ll always have the CZAR IGOR goal to remember this lost season for the Rangers’ best player.

GOALIES

DYLAN GARAND

Grade: A

For a third string goalie to give you the production that he has this season – and I don’t see how you could go any lower than an A – and especially for a guy on a rookie contract.

Outside of 2-3 games, and even then, it wasn’t all his fault – and he’s done what Sullivan has asked him to do – give the team a chance to win games.

He’s played in 15 of the team’s 21 games – and has never played more hockey in his life.

He’s done more than give the team chances to win games – and there have also been instances where he’s won games on his own too.


JOONAS KORPISALO

Grade: Incomplete

He’s played in two games this season, during the most recent road-trip, after being sidelined at the start of the season with foot fungus.

But hey – he is 2-0.

Let’s see where the season takes him, as barring injury, then he should remain as the second-string goalie, and should Garand falter, then possibly as the team’s starter.


SPENCER MARTIN AND JAMES REIMER

Grades: Incomplete

Both looked terrible and god awful in their less than one game played with the Rangers, and as a result – neither remain with the organization today.


CZAR IGOR SHESTYORKIN

Grade: A

You know the deal. Not only was he looking like a Vezina candidate prior to his injury – but a Hart candidate too.

It’s a lost season for him – and for a guy who has gained an “injury prone” reputation – and you know this latest setback, his most serious setback yet, has to be eating him alive.


That concludes our Rangers at the Quarter-Pole Progress Report Card.

Let’s now quickly put this baby to bed by covering all of the news made over the weekend.


Pavel Dorofeyev’s status for Monday night against Montreal, a game where the Rangers are celebrating their 100th birthday (their first game was on 11/16/1926 – a 1-0 Bill Cook goal against the Montreal Maroons), isn’t exactly cemented in stone. Photo Credit: NYR

The Rangers, whose return flight to New York wasn’t negatively affected (it’s nice to have a private luxury plane), obviously had an off-day on Saturday.

Come Sunday, and as talked about earlier, and the team practiced while the alumni game was going on.

The biggest thing of note was that Dorofeyev didn’t participate at the practice.

According to the team at the time, and the Russian was taken off the ice for “precautionary reasons” – which could mean anything – light gas, a foot infection caught from Korpisalo – or perhaps like the pucks he shoots – he dinged himself into a post too!

After the skate, Sullivan said that no one should worry about Dorofeyev playing on Monday night, indicating that the absence of his team’s highest-paid player wasn’t a big deal.

In other injury news, we got two more things to quickly mention:

One, Sean Durzi is nearing his comeback and should return on Sunday against Carolina.

Two, CZAR IGOR was officially placed on season ending long term injured reserve, which means that the Rangers can now use the prorated amount of his $11.5M contract to find help elsewhere.

Whether this means Dylan Larkin, Nikita Kucherov (I still don’t see this happening), or perhaps multiple lesser deals for production, remains unclear.

And in our final piece of news, the following:

Goodbye and good riddance Spencer Martin. Photo Credit: NYR

At 5:16PM Sunday, the Rangers announced a trade featuring a pair of struggling third-string goalies.

From the press release, the Blueshirts said:

New York Rangers President and General Manager Chris Drury announced today that the team has acquired goaltender Arvid Söderblom from the Chicago Blackhawks in exchange for goaltender Spencer Martin.

Söderblom, 27, appeared in five games for the Blackhawks this season. He also appeared in two games for the Rockford IceHogs of the American Hockey League (AHL), helping the team win both games he played. During the 2025-26 season, he posted an 8-13-3 record in 26 games for Chicago. On Mar. 1, he recorded his first career NHL shutout and on Apr. 4, he made his 100th career NHL start.

Across six NHL seasons, all with the Blackhawks, the Göteborg, Sweden native has appeared in 117 career games, posting a 25-68-15 record. Söderblom has appeared in 73 career AHL games, all with Rockford, posting an AHL career 38-27-7 record, a 2.78 goals against average and a .919 save percentage. He also made 10 Calder Cup Playoff appearances.

Internationally, the 6-3, 180-pound goaltender won a bronze medal with Team Sweden at the 2025 IIHF World Championship. He also represented his country at the 2026 IIHF World Championship.

Söderblom was signed as a free agent by the Blackhawks on May 13, 2021.


Obviously, then this trade basically boils down to an AHL trade – and where the Rangers better hope that Garand & Korpisalo stay healthy – or else they will take the risk of playing their sixth different goalie this season!


The Chris Kreider playing against Mika Zibanejad at M$G game will have to wait. Photo Credit: NYR

If you recall, then last year, when Kreider, then with the Ducks, returned to M$G for his first game back and Mika Zibanejad, his lover, was punished (healthy scratch) by Mike Sullivan for missing a team meeting.

In turn, and we haven’t seen Mika v. Kreider – the battle of the starstruck lovers – yet to take place at M$G.

And it won’t happen on Monday night either.

In a follow-up to a story that I talked about on Friday night – and Kreider’s injury sustained against Boston on Thursday night is serious – as Montreal announced on Saturday that CK20 will miss the next 6-8 weeks with a “lower-body injury.”

Good luck to one of my favorite Rangers of all-time in his recovery.


Finally, thanks again for staying with me – as I know this was super long.

However, I wanted to get all of these segments done when I had the time – as my real-life has been extremely busy – and where that GTA VI game may slow me down too!

(That said, and despite pre-ordering it, and I probably won’t be able to fool around with it until late Friday night! That takes me out of the $5M prize that Rockstar is offering to the first fan who completes the game!)

Back at it tomorrow night with a Rangers/Habs GAME REVIEW.

Until then?

Your favorite segment and mine, you know…

PLUGS TIME! (Buy a book and support my Rangers’ induced therapy bills. After all, I don’t run ads on this site!)


My fourth title and tenth book is now available!

“The Top 100 Villains of New York Rangers History,” is now available for sale!

For complete information, please visit: https://bluecollarblueshirts.com/rangerkillers/


The hardcover version of my first book, available now at Amazon.com

My second plug of tonight’s blog – the mandatory plug for my book, “The New York Rangers Rink of Honor and the Rafters of Madison Square Garden.”

As mentioned previously, the book is now available in hardcover, in paperback and in Kindle formats. To purchase a copy of the book, visit this link:

https://www.amazon.com/Rangers-Rafters-Madison-Square-Garden-ebook/dp/B09CM5N2WD

For those still looking for signed paperback versions of the book, I have re-ordered more copies. I now have a few signed copies for sale at $25 a pop (includes shipping price) through me directly. Here is all the information on that:

Order “The New York Rangers Rink of Honor and the Rafters of Madison Square Garden” Book Today


My four-volume set of books, “One Game at a Time – A Season to Remember,” is a game-by-game recount of the Rangers 2021-22 campaign.

My second title as an author, “One Game at a Time – A Season to Remember,” is now available in eBook, paperback and hardcover formats.

To obtain signed copies, visit: https://bluecollarblueshirts.com/onegamebook/

To purchase all four volumes on Amazon, visit: Amazon.com – “One Game at a Time.”


The greatest volume-set of books on Rangers’ history today!

“Tricks of the Trade – A Century-Long Journey Through Every Trade Made In New York Rangers’ History,” a four-volume set of books that meticulously covers every trade made in franchise history, is now on sale.

All four volumes of the title can be purchased on Amazon.com and are presented in three different formats – eBook, paperback and hardcover.

To purchase Volume I: Conn Smythe (1926) – Craig Patrick (1986), visit Amazon.com

To purchase Volume II: Phil Esposito (1986) – Neil Smith (2000), visit Amazon.com

To purchase Volume III: Glen Sather (2000-2015), visit Amazon.com

To purchase Volume IV: Jeff Gorton (2015) – Chris Drury (2022), visit Amazon.com

To purchase signed copies of all four volumes, visit https://bluecollarblueshirts.com/tricksofthetrade/


If you haven’t already, subscribe to this blog for the next update:


Now on sale!

Don’t forget to order my four-volume set of books, “Tricks of the Trade!”

If you don’t order through me, all four volumes are now available on Amazon.com

For more details, check out: https://bluecollarblueshirts.com/tricksofthetrade/

Thanks for reading.

LET’S GO RANGERS!

Sean McCaffrey

BULLSMC@aol.com

1 thought on ““The Top New York Rangers Fan Favorites Of All Time”: Looking At Every Beloved Blueshirt Through Each Era, A Complete & Detailed Rangers’ Alumni Game Report; Lundqvist Gets The Loudest Reaction – Then Scores an Empty Net Goal Too! “The 2026-27 New York Rangers Progress Report” At The Quarter-Pole of the Season; Grades & Reviews of Each Player, Dingorfeyev Dinged Up Ahead of Montreal Milestone Game, Latest NYR News (We Have a Trade!) & More”

  1. What an article Sean. Thank you. While not in the too 15 list, I’d like to suggest honorable mention to Ron Greschner.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *